LIFE'S
INJUSTICES SET THE STAGE FOR PERCEPTION OF THREAT AND AGGRESSIVE
BEHAVIOR
Lynne Namka, Ed. D., © 2001
Aggression is a human trait; it has been necessary for our survival
as a species. Aggression is innate, but it is also learned. We live
in a country where violence is becoming a way of life. Children learn
aggression through watching someone else engage in it. They choose acts
of injustice after they perceive that they live in an unjust world and
that intimidation works. Here are some forces that help create a child
who identifies with aggression.
l. Family Violence:
The Drama Triangle, described by Claude Steiner and Stephan Karpman,
is a well-accepted concept in family systems theory that stresses looking
at the roles and needs of every person in the system. The three sides
of the triangle represent the dysfunctional family with the aggressor
on one side, the victim on another and the rescuer on the third. The
rescuer can be divided into two different aspects:
(a) The negative part encourages the aggressor either by not acting
or by enabling them.
(b) The positive part that tries to get help for the members of the
family.
Children in a dysfunctional family, school or neighborhood setting learns
to internalize the behavior of all three sides of the triangle. Indeed,
all of us have these three components in us to some degree: the angry
aggressor or perpetrator, the one who has been hurt by others and the
part of us that looks the other way when we witness negative behavior
because we do not know how to stop them. With some training and understanding
we can move to the healthy part of us that tries to gain resources to
help the system.
The way out of emotional pain from family dysfunction is through education.
We can learn to observe when we shift into the three roles and learning
different ways to act. Carl Jung said that what we do not make conscious
in our life comes around to us as fate. Children learn aggression by
observing that it works in a short term, convoluted way.
Gerald Patterson's Coercion Model of Aggression says that parents who
lack parenting skills unwittingly train their children to be noncompliant
and act in antisocial ways. His research shows that poor parental discipline
skills and coercive management practices cause escalation of child-parent
conflict and increase children's aggression toward others. The child
and parents elicit negative behavior from each other. There is lack
of choice in the coercive familythere is one message "Do what the
most powerful member of the family dictates." Children feel helpless
and sense the lack of justice. Children are traumatized living in a
war zone under conditions of threat in these families. They learn coping
styles of coercion, submission and enabling in an attempt to keep themselves
safe.
Violence and abuse within a family take place when the dominant person
abuses his or her power. Typically this abuse of power is by a male
who has to prove himself by acting in macho ways and rationalizing this
behavior as his "right." The habitual use of alcohol aggravates
this pattern. Denial of how the dominant person hurts other family members
by his behavior is rampant in dysfunctional families.
Children observe the parental interactions and identify with both the
dominant and the submissive parent in the system. They internalize these
actions of both parents and carry them out in other settings. By identifying
with the victim in the family, they learn fear, weakness and helplessness.
That is why aggressive children are often a pushover for someone tougher
than themselves. They go to any length to hide these feelings of weakness
from others and from themselves.
When parents are focused on addictions and out-of-control needs, their
child's early dependency needs are not met. The child whose needs were
not met by his parents feels the lack inside. He feels "owed"
on an unconscious level. He focuses on issues of "It's not fair."
because unconsciously he felt what happened to him was not fair. And,
in a sense, he was "owed" because he missed out on basic nurturing
and love. In later years the child goes through life trying to get others
to make up for what his parents did not provide. He has limited skills
and tools to interact with people. Since he cannot gain acceptance and
friendships from others, he learns to substitute irrational anger, cruelty
to others, addictive substances, workaholic behavior or material objects
to fill his neediness.
The child raised in an angry family reacts to perceived small injustices
in daily life. He may do this outwardly or keep it in silence creating
depression. He may become demanding to make up for the injustice he
perceives. In effect, the child who has been traumatized is saying to
other people, "You owe me. Pay up!" He can't get what he wants
from his parents so he tries to get it from other people. Symbolically,
continual anger can be a covert statement to his parents, "It is
not fair. Give me my basic needs. Pay attention to me or I will hurt
someone."
People who are revengeful generally have a belief of entitlement of
"I have a right to be angry and get back at the person. I have
a right to hold on to my anger even though it hurts me." As the
old proverb says, angry children seem to cut of their nose to spite
their face. Grudges seem to run in families with some individuals feeling
pride about staying angry and being hard headed.
A five-year-old boy who had been removed from his parents due to physical
and sexual abuse came into our hospital program for children with severe
behavior and emotional problems. He had severe acting out, aggressive
behaviors toward the neighborhood children and animals. He emulated
the taunting, harassment and intimidation behavior of his father to
get what he wanted. In situations of threat, he cowered in fear, becoming
the submissive victim like his mother. As he grew in his understanding
of himself and his anger, we observed a healthier part of him that emerged.
He encouraged the new children in the program to talk about their angry
feelings and became like a junior staff member in group therapy. He
had internalized the role of a peer counselor by observing the teachers
in our school. He no longer needed to be a helpless victim or aggressive
and intimidating of others. On graduation from our program, he required
a school setting and a foster home that would strengthen the gains that
he made to think of himself as a caring, responsible boy.
2. Peer Violence:
A study of 400 children in Great Britain showed that those who had been
bullied were affected because they did not know how to respond to harassment.
The author concluded that children do not know how to deal with extreme
peer exclusion. Teachers are overworked and do not see the subtle bullying
that goes on daily.
The angry child perceives threat in situations that are unclear and
unjust. He can retaliate with impulsive anger thus distancing his classmates.
He distorts what he sees and perceives injustice in small things that
others would overlook. Peers' hostile comments only convince him that
his beliefs of threat are valid. He ends up being rejected and isolated
from his peers. Cut off from friends who can provide positive models
of behavior, he feels lonely and discouraged. He feels the world is
against him. Again his choices become limited. His cycle of perceptual
distortions and aggressive behavior continues.
Children who adopt a macho style to foster a false self-identity are
usually highly judgmental seeing things as black and white. They judge
others according to standards of toughness and macho behavior. They
cannot tolerate differences in other people according to narrow views
of life. They act tough to avoid the feelings of shame inside for being
weak. They avoid being seen as helpless and keep an illusion that they
are in control by acting tough. They fear being called a wimp and try
to measure up in the manly category so the tough people they seek to
emulate will not reject them. Their identity becomes caught up in the
old kid's game of King of the Mountain. They keep the illusion of being
in charge by the self-message of "Be big and tough and ready to
take anyone on to show how tough you are." They often have a chip-on-the-shoulder
attitude and dare others to push them into aggression. They learn that
intimidation of others can be reinforcing because it gives them a feeling
of power. Rigidity of thinking, judgmental beliefs and the need to feel
superior are the basis for prejudice and bigotry.
Cruelty to others and the need to act hard and tough are defense mechanisms
against feeling vulnerable. Children who harm others fear being hurt
and exposed for their own weakness. They go to any lengths to avoid
letting others see how frightened they are and feel unsafe if they let
their guard down so that others can see their vulnerability. The child
who acts tough begins to feel superior as a defense against feeling
the bad feelings. He rationalizes hurting others in his need to feel
superior. At times the angry child may elicit a violent response from
a punishing adult as a way of keeping the punishment under his control.
His ability to evoke a negative reaction from an authority figure keeps
him believing that he is in control even though there may be serious
consequences to his actions.
Pride in being tougher than others can keep the child caught in a cycle
of shame, egotism and misbehavior. Acting out becomes an unconscious
way to escape the terrible feelings of shame inside. Other shame-based
defenses of angry children include denial, silence, intellectualization
and distancing from the problem by placing the blame on someone else.
Impulse Control Problems: Children with attention deficit
disorder with hyperactivity often have difficulty inhibiting their teasing
behavior that later develops into aggressive behavior. Some children
do not learn skills of social interaction naturally due to a neurological
impairment. The rigidity of thinking associated with neurological impairment
causes the child to become locked into negative coping patterns of dealing
with stressful situations that bring him more stress. Some of these
children have problems of anger. Unable to control their actions, they
become the target for negative attention from others and their self-esteem
plummets. They often have deficits in thinking such as interpreting
the social cues of a situation and cause-effect reasoning. Other children
learn to avoid those with impulse control problems and they often end
up being rejected. As the children of crack addicted parents who are
born with neurological impairment, the schools will have more children
with impulse control and learning problems to deal with.
Type T Individuals: Another kind of child who is attracted to
aggression is the Type T child. Type T is a personality trait that results
in thrill seeking. Type T's are not a diagnostic category, but describe
an inner need of the under aroused individual who then seeks excitement
to feel the rush.
Individuals who have a central nervous system that enjoys being revved
up and feeds on dangerous activities are Type T's as described by psychologist
Frank Farrell. Type T children have under-aroused heart rates, sweat
glands, and skin temperatures. Their physiological systems are slower
to respond to external stimulation and they require high excitement
and risk to feel stimulated. They look for novelty, uncertainty, high
risk, variety, complexity, high intensity and conflict. The research
shows that they get a bigger rush from nicotine than other children.
Type T children seek activities that increase their adrenalin. They
enjoy going fast on bicycles over ramps, jumping off of high places
and engaging in dangerous sports. They seem to have little fear of physical
harm and are unaware of the danger in which they place themselves. They
spend more time on the street and tend to get in trouble. Some can even
get a rush out of their acts of hurting others.
Properly channeled, Type T individuals have a lot to contribute to society
because they are risk takers who enjoy challenges. Indiana Jones is
a prime example of a good guy, Type T action-seeking individual. Schools
are starting to address the Type T needs by offering Adventure Sports
classes that teach rock climbing, skiing, snow boarding and rappelling.
When Type T individuals carry a large amount of anger, they engage in
activities that are harmful to others but are exciting and reinforcing
to themselves. Children who bring guns to school may fall into this
category. Children with Conduct Disorders may fall into this category.
Bonnie and Clyde, popularized by the motion picture, are examples of
antisocial Type T individuals who lacked the skill of respecting others
and their property then gained a national reputation as counter culture
heroes.
Identify and Help Those Children Who Exhibit Warning Signs of Being
in Need: Recognize the children whose behavior suggests that they
are troubled so they can be supported before the trauma builds up. The
National Crime Prevention Council report on Stopping School Violence
gives symptoms of children in need of intervention. This web site can
be reached at www.ncpc.org/2schvio.htm
. The more of these symptoms the child displays, the greater
the chance that the child needs help. These signs say the child is crying
for help. They show a preoccupation with injustice, and an obsession
with violence, to get make the grievance and pain go away. They advise
parents to know these signs that indicate kids are troubled:
_ Lack of
interest in school.
_ Absence
of age-appropriate anger control skills.
_ Seeing themselves
as the victims.
_ Persistent
disregard for or refusal to follow the rules.
_ Cruelty
to pets or other animals.
_ History
of bullying.
_ Artwork
or writing that bleak or violent or that depicts isolation or anger.
_ Talking
constantly about weapons or violence.
_ Obsessions
with things like violent games, movies and TV shows.
_ Depression
or mood swings.
_ Talking
about or bringing a weapon (any weapon) to school.
_ Misplaced
or unwarranted jealously.
_ Involvement
with or interest in gangs.
_ Self-isolation
from family and friends.
Conduct Disorders: This diagnostic category includes the
type of student persistently engages in behavior that violates the rights
of others. They lack a conscience, a sense of guilt or remorse. They
are aggressive and have little concern for the feelings and wishes of
their peers. They may be cruel to others or to animals and have no respect
for the property of others. They project an image of being touch, although
their self-esteem is low. They may have poor frustration tolerance,
temper outbursts, irritability and an inability to see how their behavior
is the cause of their problems. They engage in fighting, stealing, destruction
of property, shoplifting, sexual force, and use weapons to get what
they want.
Oppositional Defiant Disorders: Also, a diagnostic category,
this is a pattern of angry, argumentative, spiteful behavior without
the pattern of hurting others. These children are negativistic and defy
adult authority. They are irritable, touchy, lose their temper easily
and swear. They can be vindictive toward those people they perceive
as out to get them. They cannot take responsibility for their misbehavior
and blame others for their wrongdoings. They justify their negative
actions as a reaction to circumstances that were not fair to them. Children
with this diagnosis do have a conscience and can be taught social skills
to release the hurt feelings under their defiance and control their
anger.
Gang Behavior: Gangs are groups of people who collectively engage
in bully behavior. Children with Conduct Disorders, Oppositional Defiance
Disorders and those who seek thrills may gravitate toward gangs. Gang
members are often angry individuals who seek novel, dangerous activities
through law breaking and intimidation of others. Children who start
early in life to hurt others and then are rejected by their peers are
most likely to seek out gangs.
They have poor self-esteem seek to find an identity in being a gang
member. The older gang leaders teach younger members of gangs' new ways
of intimidation and extortion. The aggressive behavior is highly reinforced
by peers' submissiveness. The sense of exaggerated pride, injustice,
and feeling entitled to use and hurt others becomes set. Violent behavior
is rationalized as a "right."
Here are the words of Pablo, a former gang member as reported in the
El Paso Times, discussing ways to reduce drug use and gang violence:
"There is too much orgullo (pride) among gang members. That
orgullo gets in the way of young people trying to go straight.
Orgullo makes you want to be tougher than the next guy. Orgullo
can be a very positive thing, but it can also help destroy young people.
Negative orgullo creates problems.... The best way to improve
the situation is for those who care to get completely involved in a
gang member's life. That means hanging out with them and getting into
the heart of them. A gang member may be abused by his dad or he may
have a single-parent mother. He may be hurting, but he'll never tell
what's hurting him. He'll never say what truly in his heart. Instead,
he'll pretend that everything's cool and all he wants is to do is party
with his homies."
3. Society Values:
We live in a culture of aggression. There is a preoccupation with the
dominator model where children learn that intimidation and aggression
toward others is not only acceptable but also desirable. Negative attitudes,
values and behaviors are celebrated. Our media often glorifies violence
and children are presented with countless acts of simulated and actual
aggression each day. Rap music that features hate and violence affects
children who take on these values. Enimen, who reportedly was bullied
as a child and spent five days in a coma after a beating, now gives
hate messages. Video games that are based on the same technology that
trains our military to kill pass the value of lack of respect for human
life on to the young people.
Without social positive skills, children grow up learning to use manipulation,
addictive behavior and violence as a way to cope with stress. They become
locked into negative coping patterns of dealing with situations that
threaten them and bring them more stress. Children who experience a
great deal of stress due to family chaos or neurological impairment
often feel like their lives are out of control.
The most common patterns of coping with threat and stress in unhealthy
environments are anger, blaming the other person, submissiveness, distractible,
hyperactive behavior or withdrawing and ignoring the problem. These
coping patterns are passed down from parent to child resulting in generations
of dysfunctional behavior. Coping styles that were learned as children
to keep the family isolated and safe do not work in adult life. To continue
to live these rules as an adult is to continue to live in considerable
pain.
Resources: Organizations, Centers, Books and Lists of Other School
Safety Web Sites
For a list of books on school violence solutions, see: http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1929749007/
qid%3D985752086/104-7640611-9528762
Colorado Parent Information and Resource Center: http://www.cpirc.org/tips/schoolviolence.htm
Educators for Social Responsibility: http://www.esrnational.org/
Conflict Resolution Education Network: http://www.crenet.org/
National School Safety Center Resources for Reporters: http://nssc1.org/index.htm
School
Violence Explained: Table of Contents
Download
all 50 pages in .rtf format
Permission
is provided for the use of the materials in this Report, provided
appropriate acknowledgment and
Dr. Namka's web site, http://members.aol.com/AngriesOut,
is given.
|